Coyles Ice Cream

36 reviews
Claimed  •  Ice Cream & Yogurt
631-666-2229
75 HOWELLS ROAD BAY SHORE , NY 11706 40.7301206664 -73.2615995407
Closed

About Coyles Ice Cream

50'S STYLE ICE CREAM PARLOR
MakIing 60 flavors of ice cream since 1985.
Come share memories while sitting at our soda fountain enjoying a Brooklyn Egg Cream or Malt.
Share a sticky finger sundae in an old fashioned booth while listening to songs from our ju...kebox..

Islip store has rear entrance with seating and music
509 main street, islip 617 5014

Photos & videos

See all
 by Coyles Ice Cream
imagesCAG2IE88 by Coyles Ice Cream
photo1 by Coyles Ice Cream
article-1265886341188-083DB44A000005DC-320783_636x300 by Coyles Ice Cream

Location & hours

  • Mon Mon 3:00 pm - 9:30 pm
  • Tue Tue 1:00 pm - 9:30 pm
  • Wed Wed 1:00 pm - 9:30 pm
  • Thu Thu 1:00 pm - 9:30 pm
  • Fri Fri 1:00 pm - 10:00 pm
  • Sat Sat 1:00 pm - 10:00 pm
  • Sun Sun 1:00 pm - 9:00 pm

Updates & tips from Coyles Ice Cream

MAPLE BACON

MAPL BACON ICE CREAM IS READY ON FRIDAY. STOP IN AND SAMPLE - I AM SURE IT WILL BECOME A FAVORITE...... MAKING ICE CREAM FOR THE PAST 28 YEARS HAS LET ME CREATE SOME WONDERFUL YET WEIRD FLAVORS. WHO WOULD EVER THINK PUTTING BACON IN ICE CREAM WOULD EVER BE SO POPULAR... Read More

Jul 26, 2012

HOLY CANNOLI ICE CREAM

STOP IN AND CHECK OUT OUR NEW SUMMER FLAVOR "HOLY CANNOLI". WE TOOK PREMIUM VANILLA ICE CREAM, RICH CANNOLI CREAM, CANNOLI SHELLS AND CHOCOLATE CHIPS TO CREATE THIS GREAT NEW FLAVOR. CHECK OUT OUR COUPONS FOR A GOOD DEAL ON A CONE. THE FIRST WEEK OF AUGUST WE WI... Read More

Jul 16, 2012

Reviews

4.8
36 reviews

Start your review

How would you rate your experience?

avatar
Nov 11, 2008

Great Place to take the kids!

Want a really fun place to take the kids. Bring back some nostalgia of the good old days and introduce your children or grandchildren to what a real ice cream parlor is.

avatar
Mar 09, 2009

AWESOME!

Talk about a traditional ice cream parlour! This place has every kid-friendly ice cream, as well as low fat and no sugar ice creams and frozen yougurts. Everyday there is a special, like Saturdays and their Sticky-Finger Sunday deals! How great!

avatar
Jul 28, 2009

THE BEST OF THE BEST............ON LONG ISLAND

Everyone knows if you want the best selection, the best tasting, and where to go to have a GREAT time.......
its COYLES
Sure it may cost a bit more - the best usually does

Steve - East Islip New York

Hecker Video-Video Transfer and Conversion Service
Oct 30, 2009

The Best Ice Cream

It's just the BEST ice cream around. Amazing selection of different flavors & they all taste great. The service is great & they make you feel right at home.
Thanks,
Lee
www.heckervideo.com
631 750-2708

avatar
Jul 21, 2009

Best ice cream shop around.

Have been coming here since they opened - and have brought friends, family and kids. Enjoyable atmosphere, and friendly staff. Love it.

avatar
Jul 09, 2009

AWESOME

I have been purchasing ice cream at Coyle's for 10 years now. There is no other ice cream that can compare to theirs. The service is great and the staff is wonderful. The ice cream is worth the drive there and back. My family will have no other ice cream cake for their birthday espcially since they can have more than one flavor at a time!