This question is currently closed
-
Soy candles -vs- regular candles
What are the advantages and disadvantages of soy candles verses regular candles. Are there certian times when one is better than the other. Is one material better for some shapes and sizes of candles?
Tags: soy, candles
Asked by CreativeConcealment from HOMOSASSA, FLAnswered 16 years ago.
The Best Answer
-
Soy and Paraffin candles are both safe to burn. Both will produce soot if not made properly and not burned properly. Keep the wick trimmed before each burn and make sure the candle is not in a drafty or high-traffic area. Soy is not a cleaner burning wax. ANY form of wax that is consumed by a flame will emit carbons and other chemicals. It is a side effect of combustion. It happens with everything that burns. Some people may just be more sensitive to what is actually burning, including the fragrance. Not all fragrance oils are created equally.
Soy wax burns cooler so it tends to last longer.
Soy candles can hold more fragrance than a paraffin candle so they tend to be more smelly, but some fragrances don't perform well in soy so there is a small trade off.
I like both waxes for different reasons. It is personal preference I think.
We carry a full line of soy, paraffin, and palm wax candles and melts and will be adding all natural soy pillars to our line soon!
Answered by Wilma Handmade LLC
9409 US Highway 19 Ste 321,
Port Richey,
FL, 34668,
727-247-5329
(Novice with 49 pts.)
Answered 16 years ago.
10 Answers
-
Candle Science and Testing - Report on the Ökometric Wax and Emissions Study
This excerpt was jointly published by the Association of European Candle Manufactures (AECM); the Asociación Latino Americano de Fabricantes de Velas (ALAFAVE); Cartill, Incorporated; the European Wax Federation (EWF); the National Candle Association (NCA); and the National Petrochemical & Refiners Association (NPRA); Sasol Wax GmbH, and The International Group, Inc. © 2008
A new, internationally funded study on candle emissions has confirmed that well-made candles of all major wax types exhibit the same clean burning behavior and pose no discernible risks to human health or indoor air quality.
The independent laboratory tests, conducted at the Bayreuth Institute of Environmental Research in Germany (Ökometric GmbH) and completed in late 2007, constitute the most extensive and rigorous scientific investigation of candle emissions to date.
In carrying out the tests, reference candles made from paraffin, soy wax, stearin, palm wax and beeswax were burned in a specialized testing chamber.
Emission gases were analyzed for more than 30 chemicals known or suspected of toxicity, health risks or respiratory irritation at elevated concentrations.
Targeted chemical groups included dioxins and furans, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, short-chain aldehydes, and volatile organic compounds. Recorded emission levels were then compared to any known relevant indoor-air standards.
The study found all of the waxes burned cleanly and safely, with no appreciable differences in burning behavior. Their combustion byproducts were virtually identical in composition and quantity, with all emission levels registering far below the most restrictive of any applicable indoor-air standards.
A similar but less extensive study of paraffin, stearin and beeswax candles was conducted by the Bayreuth Institute in 1994.
By comparison, the 2007 study added soy and palm to the candle waxes tested, and expanded the target analytes to include an extensive number of volatile organic compounds as well as the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, dioxins/furans and short-chain aldehydes investigated in 1994. No significant differences in candle emission behavior could be detected between the 1994 and 2007 investigations.
A global consortium of industry groups and companies sponsored the Ökometric study. Funding was provided by the Association of European Candle Manufactures (AECM); the Asociación Latino Americano de Fabricantes de Velas (ALAFAVE); Cartill, Incorporated; the European Wax Federation (EWF); the National Candle Association (NCA); and the National Petrochemical & Refiners Association (NPRA).
Sasol Wax GmbH and The International Group, Inc. contributed through the preparation and certification of the testing samples and provision of project management personnel.
Significance of Study
The 2007 Ökometric study has greatly expanded the body of credible scientific data on candle emissions and burning behavior. In addition to demonstrating that the combustion byproducts of all major candle waxes are virtually identical in composition and quantity, the study reconfirms the lack of health or air-quality concerns with candles. A formal paper on the Ökometric study will be submitted to a peer-reviewed journal for publication.
FAQ
Should I be concerned about burning candles and the effect on my indoor air quality?
An internationally funded study on candle emissions performed in 2007 has confirmed that well-made candles of all major wax types pose no discernible risks to human health or indoor air quality.
In carrying out the tests, reference candles made from paraffin, soy wax, stearin, palm wax and beeswax were burned in a specialized testing chamber.
Emission gases were analyzed for more than 300 chemicals known or suspected of toxicity, health risks or respiratory irritation at elevated concentrations.
The study found all of the waxes burned cleanly and safely, with no appreciable differences in burning behavior. Their combustion byproducts were virtually identical in composition and quantity, with all emission levels registering far below the most restrictive of any applicable indoor-air standards.
Do soy candles burn cleaner than paraffin candles?
An internationally funded study on candle emissions performed in 2007 has confirmed that well-made candles of all major wax types exhibit the same clean burning behavior.
In carrying out the tests, reference candles made from paraffin, soy wax, stearin, palm wax and beeswax were burned in a specialized testing chamber.
Again, the study found all of the waxes burned cleanly and safely, with no appreciable differences in burning behavior. Their combustion byproducts were virtually identical in composition and quantity, with all emission levels registering far below the most restrictive of any applicable indoor-air standards.
Answered by Gold Canyon Candles ~ CLOSED PERMANENTLY
Leesburg,
VA, 20175,
111-111-1111
(Novice with 16 pts.)
Answered 16 years ago. -
My Niece makes and sells Soy Candles on Etsy. She says they burn cleaner, hold fragrances longer .
Answered by ArtRave: Ave Hurley Illustrations ~ Featured Artists NetworkS
546 Glen Ave,
Johnsonburg,
PA, 15845,
814-596-5196
(Novice with 9 pts.)
Answered 16 years ago. -
I love soy candles. I think they burn much longer and they really hold their fragfrance.
Links: www,kandkfloral.artsefest.com
Answered by Frugal Fortune
15408 Madison Avenue,
Lakewood,
OH, 44107,
216-889-3701
(Mentor with 524 pts.)
Answered 16 years ago. -
So far, I have found that soy candles burn cleaner than regular candles, however, that is provided you care for them in the same manner. All candles you should trim the wicks to 1/4 inch to avoid "sooting". Soy tends to have a better scent throw, but depending on the candlemaker, you won't notice a big difference here because most of us are dedicated to making all our candles smell wonderful - no matter the medium!Answered by Candles, Bath and More 803 W. 8TH Street, Washington, MO, 63090, 636-234-6740 (Novice with 1 pts.)
Answered 16 years ago. -
Any candle can burn clean if it is made properly. Each type of wax, whether it be gel, paraffin, soy, vegetable, beeswax, etc. has its own properties. A responsible and experienced candlemaker should know those properties to make a quality candle. A responsible candle burner/customer should know the safety precautions and how to burn candles safely. So soy vs. paraffin vs. gel vs. vegetable wax vs. etc.....It's a PERSONAL preference!Answered by stclaircandlelady (Novice with 18 pts.)
Answered 16 years ago. -
There has been the age old question: is soy candles better than regular candles. I'm assuming you are comparing soy to paraffin. Many people say that paraffin emits alot of soot and is not good for the air. Some others state there is no truth in it. For me, I've noticed that a paraffin candle irates my nose and I cannot stand to smell them for a prolonged time. Also I've noticed that the scents are not as true or comforting compared to a soy candle.
For me, the advantage of using a soy candle is that we are supporting our American farmers, the burn times are longer and cleaner and they just smell better, to me anyway.
So the best is to weigh the options yourself. Try a regular candle then try a soy candle. See if you notice any difference. Only you can be the best judge of which one you like better :).
Answered by For Every Home Candles & Home Decor
Knoxville,
TN, 37919,
866-317-3509
(Novice with 2 pts.)
Answered 16 years ago. -
How about no buring or any wicks and no flame. Scensty systems warm the wax with a low watt blub. over 80 warmer styles and over 8- scents to choose from and they end up costong less than candles. One scent bar lasts about 60 hrs, compare that to a candle and the scent bars are only $5
Links: www.TheScentedGift.com
Answered by Scentsy ~ Independent Consultant
Tonya Harper - Independent Lead Consultant,
Riverside,
CA, 92503,
909-770-2712
(Novice with 104 pts.)
Answered 16 years ago. -
As a candle maker, and as a regular candle user, I am going to suggest you decide for yourself. You really have to burn a paraffin candle, and then burn a soy candle. It really doesn't matter how many reports say one is better or worse than the other. I agree one is better, but if you have not burned both, you won't notice what's better about one over the other. There is a noticeable difference between the two. You don't even need reports or tests to figure it out.
Answered by Cornelius Hardy Collection
www.scentsbyhardy.com,
Orlando,
FL, 32835,
424-354-9198
(Novice with 14 pts.)
Answered 16 years ago. -
Regardless of whether the candle is Soy or Paraffin or some other wax, it is most important to find a company that designs the candle to burn properly. Meaning, they need to conduct testing to ensure that the fragrance oil, wax, wick and jar design is appropriate for maximum candle-burning performance. Hope this helps!
www.canterburycabin.com
Answered by Canterbury Cabin Soap & Candle Company
King Road (online business only),
Greene,
NY, 13778,
607-656-5448
(Novice with 5 pts.)
Answered 15 years ago.