HMO VS Private Insurance
Health Maintenance Organizations (HMO) and Preferred Provider Organizations (PPO) are two types of major health care insurance systems. They are similar in that they are both managed health care plans, which means health care providers and hospitals contract with various health insurers to provide services at negotiated rates. They vastly differ in operational/network structure, costs, choices of coverage and flexibility.
Structure
HMOs, made popular during the 1970s, particularly during the early Nixon administration, are designed as a two-step system to manage health care by emphasizing early prevention in addition to providing healthcare services (treatment). This differs from traditional services which places the emphasis on “after the fact” treatment for injury and illnesses.
Network
HMOs require individuals to choose a primary care physician (PCP) at the time of enrollment. From there, your PCP will be charged with coordinating all of your health care needs. PPOs do not have this particular requirement.
Referral
With an HMO, you must get a referral from your primary doctor if you need to visit a specialist. Under a PPO plan, you are allowed to visit your choice of specialist or any other doctor without input from your primary physician.
Location
HMOs operate in particular areas, which are designated by specific counties and/or zip codes. All medical services must be administered within the service area of your HMO policy. PPO plans do not have location coverage restrictions.
Premiums/Deductibles
HMOs are about the most affordable health care plans offered. Their policies have lower monthly premiums, have low to no co-payments for physician visits and have no deductibles.
PPO policies have various levels of deductibles and co-payments, depending coverage you choose. With a PPO, you pay lower premiums upfront but then pay a higher amount when you use the services.
Flexibility
A PPO offers much more flexibility and choice in health care options for its members being that they are not limited to health care providers only within that particular network. HMOs are a bit more rigid, being that patients must follow a protocol of physician referrals limited to those within the network.
Disadvantages
If a member of an HMO plan visits a doctor outside of the HMO network without a referral from their primary care provider, the insurer will not pay for the services rendered.
Similarly, if a member of a preferred provider organization uses the services from a non-PPO service provider, the PPO will generally allow for less financial reimbursements.