Ben & Jack's Steak House

13 reviews
Claimed  •  Catering Services , Restaurants
212-682-5678
219 E 44th St New York, NY 10017 40.752 -73.9729

Photos & videos

tmpUJKreW by Ben & Jack's Steak House
tmpIQMQcw by Ben & Jack's Steak House

Location & hours

  • Mon Mon 11:05 am - 10:05 pm
  • Tue Tue 11:05 am - 10:05 pm
  • Wed Wed 11:05 am - 10:05 pm
  • Thu Thu 11:05 am - 10:05 pm
  • Fri Fri 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
  • Sat Sat 4:00 pm - 11:00 pm
  • Sun Sun 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm

Reviews

0.0
13 reviews

Start your review

How would you rate your experience?

avatar
Jan 10, 2012

Great Place to Eat in the City!

We ate at Ben and Jack's last night for the first time. From the moment we walked in the staff was attentive, warm, and friendly. We were seated immediately in a cozy alcove which made our experience even nicer. Our waiter was knowledgeable, and very helpful with ou...r selections from the wine to the entree. The steak was cooked to perfection, and served expertly. I highly recommend the fries, and the mushrooms, both were a taste sensation. We also had the Ben and Jack's seafood dish which can be made with either a red sauce, or white sauce. We chose the red and were so glad we did. It was a masterpiece of tastes. Dessert was the perfect ending with cheeses cakes, carrot cake, key lime pie, and the most wonderful whipped cream we had ever eaten. \t\n\t\nIf you are looking for a wonderful dining experience, this is the place to go. Oh don't forget to try the warm home-made potato chips while enjoying your cocktail, you'll want to eat the whole basket!!!

avatar
Jan 25, 2010

The BEST Steak House!!

Just consistently great steaks, seafood, fish and sides. BY FAR the best steak house in the city and has such a great atmosphere/friendly staff too. I've been at the 44th Street and 5th Avenue locations several times this past month, and I can never get enough. Looking forward to my next Porterhouse there!

avatar
Sep 26, 2009

OK at Best - Not the Greatest Steakhouse

We decided to give Ben and Jacks a try. I've definitely been to better steakhouses. The waiter was nice, but forgot to give me my mash potatoes to go, which was disappointing. The steak was decent, but I prefer Ruth Chris. The ambiance was tacky, in fact there was a big... hole in the bathroom stall. \t\n\t\nFrankly, I expect more, and have gotten much better for a meal that costs $200.

avatar
Feb 15, 2009

waay overrated

this restaurant is waay over rated. the tables are crammed together so you feel as if your having a community meal. we had two filets. one we had to send back because we ordered it med rare and it was brought to use med to med well. the steaks were tender but tasted dr...y if that makes any sense... it was definietly not impressive or mouth watering. the service was really slooooow. finally the oddest part about the meal is that i called ahead and told them it was my bf birthday thinking they would bring out a small cake or sing or something...anyways after getting there i reminded the waiter about the birthday.. finally after not getting the typical birthday response (cake) we decided to order carrot cake. the waiter brought the carrot cake out with a candle in it and charged us for it. :).... i would with out a doubt choose ruth chris or some other well known steakhouse over ben and jacks if you want to guarantee your going to have a steak that is worth remembering.

avatar
Mar 03, 2008

Greatest place ever!

I went to the steakhouse one saturday evening with a few friends. It was great from the begining. At first they have a beautiful young lady who greeted us, she was very kind and respectful. The service was excellent, the waiters very quick and talkative. The food was a...bsolutely delicious. Everything was outstanding! I recommend it to anyone, and the atmosphere is great for all ages. \t\nSimply TWO THUMBS UP and if u r ever in NYC u MUST try this place out!

avatar
Sep 24, 2007

Avoid if your from the Younger crowd...

Great Steak!!! - That says it all about this place. Because they surely don't have anything else. I went there with some friends for some NY style good steak. The waiter was in-attentive, and we got the impression we were looked down upon for being "younger". We ar...e in our mid-twenties and were taken aback by this attitude. The decor was great, the food was fantastic. But service can make or break an experience...and we will not be going back there if we are treated as we were.