Osman Blake

2 reviews
Claimed   •  Business Services
308-917-0297
Begum Kot Lahore Marion, WI 54950 44.6717624 -88.8875681

The $8,000 Mistake That Changed How I Sell Engagement Rings

Jun 24, 2025

I have been in the jewelry business since 1996. Third generation. My grandfather, my father, now me. You would think after 30 years I would have seen it all.

But a few years back, my best friend bought a $10,000 engagement ring from me. I gave him my best price. The ring was beautiful. He proposed, she said yes, everyone was happy.

Then, months later, he mentioned to me in passing that he figured I probably made about $8,000 on the deal.

Eight thousand dollars. On a ten thousand dollar ring. That is what he thought of me.

I did not make $8,000. I made nowhere near that. But I realized in that moment that even my best friend, someone who knew me personally, had no idea what jewelry actually costs to make. If he thought I was ripping him off at that level, what did strangers think?

That conversation is why I started TrueSanity.

What I actually sell now

TrueSanity is built on one simple idea. Show the customer exactly what the ring costs to make. The stone. The metal. The labor. The shipping. All of it broken down, line by line, on every single product page.

Nobody else in the industry does this. I know because I looked for years. The model I ended up copying was not from jewelry at all. It was Everlane, the clothing brand. They were publishing their cost breakdown on t-shirts and jeans. I remember thinking, if they can do it with a $30 shirt, I can do it with a $3,000 ring.

If you want to Shop Engagement Rings this way, you can see it for yourself. Every ring has its full cost disclosed. No games, no marketing math, no pretending.

Why so many buyers are asking about sapphires

Here is something I did not expect when we launched. I assumed diamonds would be 90 percent of the business. They are still the biggest category, but sapphires have quietly become one of the fastest growing things we sell.

Some of that goes back to Kate Middleton. That blue sapphire engagement ring (originally Princess Diana's) put the stone back on the map and it never really left. But the bigger reason is that buyers today want something that feels more personal than another round brilliant diamond on the hand.

Women's sapphire rings are also a smarter deal per carat than diamonds. A 2 carat sapphire in a beautiful setting can land well under what a 1 carat diamond solitaire costs. You get a bigger center stone, a more unique look, and often a nicer setting for the same money.

Sapphires are also tough. They sit at a 9 on the Mohs hardness scale. Only diamonds are harder. That matters when you are wearing a ring every single day for the rest of your life.

What I tell every customer now

Three things, every time:

  1. Ask the jeweler for a price breakdown. If they will not give you one, walk away. It is 2026. There is no excuse for hiding what a ring costs to make.
  2. Do not be afraid of colored stones. Sapphires in particular are a smart, beautiful, durable choice for someone who wants something different without giving up quality.
  3. Trust the jeweler who tells you what they actually make on the deal. Those people are rare. They are also the ones worth buying from.

Thirty years in this business, one lost friendship over a price assumption, and a company built out of that one bad conversation. If TrueSanity ever helps another buyer avoid the exchange I had with my friend, I will consider that a win.

See more updates & tip